Manager -- Willie RandolphLook, I really like Willie. I think he's the right energy for New York and his gazillion championship rings should be enough to earn any player's respect. That being said, I think I have the same criticisms many others have of Willie's performance. I would have liked to have seen a lot more bunting, hitting and running, etc. and better strategic use of the bullpen. You have to admit that some of his moves were head scratchers. As for the "lack of emotion" thing, I don't put too much stock into it. Jumping up and down is probably the best way to quickly lose credibility and respect in the clubhouse. That being said, I wish there was more appreciable and overt action taken during the final slide of the season.
Grade: B-Pitching Coach -- Rick Peterson I'm almost ready to stop drinking the Rick Peterson Kool-Aid. The Mets team E.R.A went up every single month from April to September, and while Oliver Perez winning 15 games is a huge turnaround--Peterson's inability to put the "arm-angle" issue to bed has been source of extreme frustration for me. Of course, Peterson can only work with the talent at his disposal and Mets' pitching talent wasn't going to blow anyone's doors off no matter who the pitching coach was. It's just that I'm growing tired of hearing about what a guru this guy is without ever getting the big-time payoff. And If I'm getting tired of this song and dance I can only imagine how the pitching staff feels.
Grade: C-Hitting Coach -- Howard JohnsonAfter Rick Down was fired and Hojo came aboard there were only two offensive changes that made an impression with me: 1) David Wright getting his stroke back; and 2) Jose Reyes losing his. From everything I'm hearing, Reyes' problems may have had a lot more to do with non-baseball issues than anything else--so I'm ready to discount how this plays into Hojo's performance. As for David, the results are hard to argue with. As for Hojo's vs. Rick Down's work with the rest of the team---it basically seemed like a wash for me.
Grade: BFirst Base -- Carlos DelgadoCarlos didn't perform this year at all and had the worst single season numbers of his career. It seemed as though he was overmatched at every turn, and just about every big hit was a "close your eyes, swing hard and pray" stroke of luck. It also seemed as though some of the fire in his belly had dissipated from 2006 to 2007. And hey--where was that diary of his? I think I saw him writing in it three times this year. Was he hurt? Is he over-the-hill? Was the new baby part of the problem? I don't know, but the bottom line is that Carlos was nothing short of Mr. Rallykiller in 2007.
Grade: DSecond Base -- Luis CastilloWith the exception of a creaky knee, there was a lot to like about Luis. A great situational hitter, bunter, contact swinger, base-stealer, etc., etc., etc. Not to mention the fact that despite the knee he remains one of the most solid second basemen in the league. In retrospect, my biggest issue with Luis revolves around rumors that he was a bad influence on Reyes--running around Long Island every night getting blitzed. That being said, a rumor is a rumor. Can't take points away for that.
Grade: B+Second Base -- Ruben GotayOffensively, Ruben Gotay was a revelation from the left side of the plate. His swing was sweet and he always seemed to hit the ball HARD--something that I always tend to look for in up and coming players (although it never really amounted to anything with Jay Payton). Then again, from the right side....well, not so much. Also, towards the end of the season it seemed like he was striking out left and right in big situations. As for the defense---yikes. My grandmother has a better double play pivot. The bottom line is that Gotay has talent but needs a lot of work. If the Mets re-sign Castillo there just isn't going to be such an opportunity for him to grow/blossom.
Grade: BShortstop -- Jose ReyesIf this was a midseason report card his grade would be A+. What a difference a second half makes. Jose Reyes' season ranks with some of the most disappointing seasons in recent memory for me. I'm sorry, but for me it ranks right up there with Bernard Gilkey's 1997 collapse. After 2006, 2007 was poised to be Reyes' breakout year and it just didn't happen. It was almost as if Jimmy Rollins and Hanley Ramirez stole his karma. Also gone in the second half seemed be that ever-present smile and love for the game. What happened? Lots of rumors out there may explain things, but it may all boil down to a case of him reading his own press and falling in love with the stolen base over the rest of his tools. 78 steals is great--but not when it equates to only 88 wins.
Grade: C-Third Base -- David WrightWhat's not to like? Okay, maybe the defense. 21 errors--many of which came on routine throws to first--is a bit hard to swallow from a player who has the ability to do better. But, needless to say, this is a sin easily forgiven. Just please--PLEASE--never compete in a home run contest ever again.
Grade: ARight Field -- Moises AlouHey, I can't take points away for getting hurt and I never got the sense that Alou was dragging his heels on the DL. This is a man that wants to play. And when he did play he raked--.341, 13, 49 and a Met record 30 game hitting streak in just 87 games. Project that over 140 games, and, well....don't make me do the math--but it would be real good. As for his defense, Alou was adequate and gave us the best he had.
Grade: A-Center Field -- Carlos BeltranA second consecutive solid year for Beltran. Stellar defense and .276 33 112 at the plate. What's weird is that if I didn't know these stats I would never have guessed his numbers looked so good. It's almost like Carlos puts up big numbers in little spots (or, to no fault of his own, in games we ended up losing). Also, I think 2007 marked the official death knell of Carlos Beltran being a stolen base threat. When he was signed in 2005 this was supposed to be a big part of his game, but it's never really materialized in New York. And then there's the matter of his seemingly constant leg injuries. All in all a solid, but somehow unspectacular year.
Grade: B+Right Field -- Shawn Green Admit it. There was some small part of you that secretly hoped Green would magically regain a modicum of his former prowess and hit at least 20 homers this year. But, alas, those days are long gone (and they've been gone since undergoing major shoulder surgery years back when he was still a Dodger). For the most part, Green did the best that could be expected of him and seemed to adjust to being a line drive singles and doubles hitter as the year went on. Going forward, Green would make an excellent spot/role player, but not much more.
Grade: BRight Field -- Lastings MilledgePutting behavioral issues and immaturity aside, I am now officially a Lastings Milledge proponent/believer. The kid's got talent and he just needs a chance. There probably isn't a player on the team that hits the ball harder than him, and he has an innately intimidating presence at the plate (something the Mets sorely lack). Of course, there is the matter of that pesky curveball, but this is something that will come with time. His defense, while still shaky, seemed to improve from a downright scary performance in 2006. Unless he's included in a trade for Johan Santana or someone similar, he MUST be given a lot of rope in 2008.
Grade: B+Catching -- Paul Lo DucaI've said in the past that it's hard for me to picture Paul Lo Duca in anything but a Mets uniform. I know it's only been a couple of years, but when I think of the Mets I think of Paul right up there with David and Jose. And, needless to say, he's New York through and through (even though he was raised in Arizona). All that being said, it's kind of sad that Ramon Castro almost topped him statistically while playing in only 52 games. As for behind the plate, his already diminished skills seemed to slip even further. Paul, I love ya, but I think 2007 has to be your last in Queens--unless you're willing to be a backup--which you aren't. Just please don't sign with the Yankees.
Grade: C+Catching -- Ramon CastroWe're talking some serious numbers for 52 games: .285 11 31. I know it would be a near miracle for him to play in 140 games, but if he did those numbers project to about 25 homers and over 80 RBIs. With his creaky arthritic back I don't think we could ever count on him to be a starter, but his 2007 season should slot him in nicely for a big 2008 free-agent payoff in a weak catching market.
Grade: A- Pitcher -- Tom GlavineHow can one grade Tom Glavine without taking the last game of the season into account? You almost want to fail him for that performance alone--and if you weren't prepared to flunk him for that--how about flunking him just for saying that he "wasn't devastated" by the loss. I mean, wow. C'mon Tommy. As for the season itselff, he slotted in nicely for what would be expected of a #4 starter on a championship team. Unfortunately, Glavine was the go to guy all too often. While there were still moments where Glavine could confuse and frustrate young and/or impatient hitters, good hitters hit him hard and often. The bottom line is that without the extra two inches off the plate he used to get in the 1990's he's just not a top of the rotation starter anymore. Crafty? Yes. Smart? Yes. Someone to be counted on? No.
I'm now preparing a bottle of Jack Daniels just in case he invokes his $13 million option for 2008.
Grade: CPitcher -- John Maine:Well at least now we have an explanation for where his season went after the All-Star break (bad hip). Basically, at 15-10 with a sub 4 E.R.A. you have to happy with what he gave you. Also, with the exception of Oliver Perez, he was the only pitcher on the staff that showed flashes of dominance. His last performance of the season was nearly the first no-hitter in Mets history and you have to be excited about things to come. I also really like his demeanor. Not too high, not too low. Still needs to work on flying off the rails in tough spots.
Grade: A-Pitcher -- Oliver PerezOkay...deep breath... I really have to force myself not to allow Perez's final outing of the year to unfairly influence my evaluation his entire 2007 body of work. At the end of the day we all have to remember that in just one year he went from 3-13 and an E.R.A. over 6 to 15-10 3.56. That's pretty impressive no matter how you look at it. And while Willie and Rick can talk about arm-slots until they're blue in the face, we all know that Perez's problems begin and end in the area directly above his shoulders. If this guy could just get his head straight and focus he'd be a potential Cy Young candidate.
Grade: B+Pitcher -- Orlando HernandezHow old is he? 36, 41, 52? I don't know and I really don't care. When healthy, El Duque can toy with hitters like my cat messing with a three-legged mouse. As has always been the case it all comes down to staying off the DL. When he was healthy and available in 2007, Hernandez was our best and most reliable pitcher.
Grade: A-Pitcher -- Pedro MartinezAll I can really grade him on is coming back from rotator cuff surgery in record time and making a legitimate late-season contribution. Pedro is still Pedro, and hopefully he'll come back even stronger in 2008.
Grade: APitcher -- Mike PelfreyDespite a 3-8, 5.57 mark for 2007, there's no question that this kid has great stuff. It's just a question of when and if he'll be able to harness it. In a single game against the Braves this summer we saw a glimpse of everything Mike Pelfrey can be. Will we see similar performances in the future? The operative word with Pelfrey is patience. I know this is New York, but Pelfrey must be given even more room to pitch and fail if he is ever going to blossom.
Grade: C+Bullpen:Aaron Sele: Often made me wonder if Desi Relaford was available to pitch in long relief.
Grade: D+Guillermo Mota: How can he still throw 96+ and yet still be so bad?
Grade: D-Scott Schoeneweis: Came on late, but was brutal early. Apparently pitched with a bum knee all year.
Grade: C-Jorge Sosa: Showed some early flashes but eventually also showed us why he's been on three teams in two years.
Grade: CJoe Smith: Made me forget about Chad Bradford...until June. Started out as a potential Rookie of the Year candidate and ended up falling off a cliff. Dead arm? Maybe.
Grade: BDuaner Sanchez: I know he didn't pitch, but I'm still pissed that he couldn't eat a bag of Fritos and call it a night like a normal person. Damn you Duaner.
Grade: FPedro Feliciano: Our most reliable guy out of the pen--which isn't necessarily flattering amongst this company. Definitely had a solid year but went south late like everyone else.
Grade: B+Billy Wagner: His 2007 numbers look fine on paper, but the results didn't show on the field. Made the concept of a 1-2-3 inning seem like science fiction. A little too Armando Benitez-like for comfort.
Grade: B- Overall Cumulative Team Grade: C-Looking back at 2007 I have to say that this was a remarkably frustrating year from start to finish. Literally speaking, I think the only time I was ever really confident and pumped about this team was coming out of St. Louis 3-0 and April. Man, does that seem like a million years ago. Sure, April and May showed some promise, but we were all panicking about David Wright--which threw a lot of cold water on whatever enthusiasm we might have had at that point. For the rest of the year the Mets were essentially a .500 team and sustained absolutely zero sustained momentum. Win one, lose one. Win three, lose two. Lose four, win three. It just wasn't fun. The trading deadline brought little excitement for the second consecutive year, although the addition of Luis Castillo did ultimately prove fruitful. Then came the homestretch---which I'm certain you don't need me to remind you about. Any season that has the word "collapse" associated with it can not be considered a good one.